Circle Y Xtreme Performance Reiner Saddle
The Circle Y Xtreme Performance Reiner is positioned as a performance-first reining saddle with a modern, lightweight tree and close-contact seat that helps riders execute fast spins and sliding stops with confidence. Technically advanced components and factory consistency make it a smart mid-to-high range option for riders wanting near-pro features without the custom price of the top-tier makers; it is generally more performance-oriented than the more traditional Billy Cook and Crates models while undercutting the premium price of the Martin Sherry Cervi show line.
Ultra close-contact
Featherlight build
Ultra close-contact
Featherlight build
Review Summary
"Riders praise its balanced seat, durable build and excellent leg position for reining patterns; some note it runs slightly narrow and is heavier than comparable models."
Silver-trim flair
Deep, close-contact seat designed to keep the rider secure during spins and sliding stops.
Silver-trim flair
Deep, close-contact seat designed to keep the rider secure during spins and sliding stops.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Skill Development & Mastery
Recreational Enjoyment
The Circle Y Xtreme Performance Reiner is positioned as a performance-first reining saddle with a modern, lightweight tree and close-contact seat that helps riders execute fast spins and sliding stops with confidence. Technically advanced components and factory consistency make it a smart mid-to-high range option for riders wanting near-pro features without the custom price of the top-tier makers; it is generally more performance-oriented than the more traditional Billy Cook and Crates models while undercutting the premium price of the Martin Sherry Cervi show line.
Ultra close-contact
Featherlight build
Silver-trim flair
Deep, close-contact seat designed to keep the rider secure during spins and sliding stops.
Durable, hand-finished leather with reinforced rigging and a modern stable tree for rider balance.
Ultra close-contact
Featherlight build
Silver-trim flair
Deep, close-contact seat designed to keep the rider secure during spins and sliding stops.
Durable, hand-finished leather with reinforced rigging and a modern stable tree for rider balance.
$2,500-3,500 USD
Billy Cook Reining Saddle Pro Series
The Billy Cook Pro Series offers classic western craftsmanship and durable, no-nonsense construction that appeals to trainers and amateurs looking for reliable performance at a value price. Financially it typically undercuts the higher-end show saddles on this list, trading some of the newest technical tree advancements for proven, heavy-duty materials—making it a cost-effective choice compared with the more tech-focused Circle Y and the premium Martin Sherry Cervi model.
Handcrafted durability
Deep molded seat
Handcrafted durability
Deep molded seat
Review Summary
"Seen as a reliable, comfortable and good-value traditional reiner with solid leather and workmanship; a few users report a longer break-in period and occasional hardware wear."
Old-school charm
Classic reining seat shape with a supportive cantle that suits competitive maneuvers.
Old-school charm
Classic reining seat shape with a supportive cantle that suits competitive maneuvers.
Skill Development & Mastery
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
The Billy Cook Pro Series offers classic western craftsmanship and durable, no-nonsense construction that appeals to trainers and amateurs looking for reliable performance at a value price. Financially it typically undercuts the higher-end show saddles on this list, trading some of the newest technical tree advancements for proven, heavy-duty materials—making it a cost-effective choice compared with the more tech-focused Circle Y and the premium Martin Sherry Cervi model.
Handcrafted durability
Deep molded seat
Old-school charm
Classic reining seat shape with a supportive cantle that suits competitive maneuvers.
Quality tooled leather construction with practical hardware and sturdy rigging points.
Handcrafted durability
Deep molded seat
Old-school charm
Classic reining seat shape with a supportive cantle that suits competitive maneuvers.
Quality tooled leather construction with practical hardware and sturdy rigging points.
$1,200-1,900 USD
Crates Classic Reiner 2499
The Crates Classic Reiner 2499 blends traditional hand-finished styling with a balanced tree designed for reining maneuvers, delivering solid stability and rider security in the show pen. It occupies a middle ground financially and technically—offering more classic leatherwork and a dependable fit that many prefer over ultra-modern performance trees, while often costing less than the custom Sherry Cervi pieces but more than entry-level Billy Cook options.
Solid leather-build
Instant close-contact
Solid leather-build
Instant close-contact
Review Summary
"An affordable entry-to-mid-level reiner liked for its price, decent fit and lightweight design, though reviewers mention lower-end leather and occasional stitching or hardware issues over extended use."
Tooling-style swagger
Traditional reining profile with a deep seat and narrow twist for close leg contact.
Tooling-style swagger
Traditional reining profile with a deep seat and narrow twist for close leg contact.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Skill Development & Mastery
The Crates Classic Reiner 2499 blends traditional hand-finished styling with a balanced tree designed for reining maneuvers, delivering solid stability and rider security in the show pen. It occupies a middle ground financially and technically—offering more classic leatherwork and a dependable fit that many prefer over ultra-modern performance trees, while often costing less than the custom Sherry Cervi pieces but more than entry-level Billy Cook options.
Solid leather-build
Instant close-contact
Tooling-style swagger
Traditional reining profile with a deep seat and narrow twist for close leg contact.
Hand-tooled leather and a skirt design that promotes stability during quick maneuvers.
Solid leather-build
Instant close-contact
Tooling-style swagger
Traditional reining profile with a deep seat and narrow twist for close leg contact.
Hand-tooled leather and a skirt design that promotes stability during quick maneuvers.
$1,400-2,200 USD
Martin Saddlery Sherry Cervi Crown C Reiner
The Martin Saddlery Sherry Cervi Crown C Reiner is the market-leading, pro-level choice favored by top competitors for its premium materials, refined fit systems and show-ready styling that prioritize both horse comfort and rider balance. As the priciest option on the list, it brings custom-level adjustability and finish that outclasses mid-range alternatives like Circle Y and Crates in technical refinement, making it the go-to for riders who need top performance and are willing to pay a premium.
Showring pedigree
Precision fit
Showring pedigree
Precision fit
Review Summary
"Consistently rated as a top show saddle — exceptional balance, close contact and high-quality craftsmanship favored by professionals, with high price being the main common drawback."
Custom bling
Premium, custom-oriented build with a competition-focused seat designed in collaboration with a champion reiner.
Custom bling
Premium, custom-oriented build with a competition-focused seat designed in collaboration with a champion reiner.
Skill Development & Mastery
Recreational Enjoyment
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
The Martin Saddlery Sherry Cervi Crown C Reiner is the market-leading, pro-level choice favored by top competitors for its premium materials, refined fit systems and show-ready styling that prioritize both horse comfort and rider balance. As the priciest option on the list, it brings custom-level adjustability and finish that outclasses mid-range alternatives like Circle Y and Crates in technical refinement, making it the go-to for riders who need top performance and are willing to pay a premium.
Showring pedigree
Precision fit
Custom bling
Premium, custom-oriented build with a competition-focused seat designed in collaboration with a champion reiner.
Top-grade leather and craftsmanship with options for personalized fit and tree specifications.
Showring pedigree
Precision fit
Custom bling
Premium, custom-oriented build with a competition-focused seat designed in collaboration with a champion reiner.
Top-grade leather and craftsmanship with options for personalized fit and tree specifications.
$3,000-4,500 USD
Double J Pozzi Pro Reining Saddle
The Double J Pozzi Pro pairs hand-crafted attention with a Pozzi-style performance tree to deliver responsive close-contact feel and nimble handling tailored to reining work. Its technical advantage is the specialized tree and balance that approach pro-level performance while often presenting a sharper price-to-performance ratio than fully custom show saddles; compared with Billy Cook it offers more modern reining-specific features, and compared with Martin it is a more affordable alternative for riders seeking advanced function without full custom pricing.
Italian-crafted leather
Speed-turn balance
Italian-crafted leather
Speed-turn balance
Review Summary
"Highly regarded for its modern design, comfortable seat and premium construction; buyers frequently praise performance but note it’s expensive and can be on the heavier side."
Contoured comfort
Designed for reining performance with a close-contact skirt and a secure, deep seat.
Contoured comfort
Designed for reining performance with a close-contact skirt and a secure, deep seat.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Skill Development & Mastery
Recreational Enjoyment
The Double J Pozzi Pro pairs hand-crafted attention with a Pozzi-style performance tree to deliver responsive close-contact feel and nimble handling tailored to reining work. Its technical advantage is the specialized tree and balance that approach pro-level performance while often presenting a sharper price-to-performance ratio than fully custom show saddles; compared with Billy Cook it offers more modern reining-specific features, and compared with Martin it is a more affordable alternative for riders seeking advanced function without full custom pricing.
Italian-crafted leather
Speed-turn balance
Contoured comfort
Designed for reining performance with a close-contact skirt and a secure, deep seat.
Hand-tooled leather finish and reinforced rigging for durability under demanding use.
Italian-crafted leather
Speed-turn balance
Contoured comfort
Designed for reining performance with a close-contact skirt and a secure, deep seat.
Hand-tooled leather finish and reinforced rigging for durability under demanding use.
$2,200-3,200 USD